Canadian Policing Research Catalogue

Making and breaking barriers : assessing the value of mounted police units in the UK / Chris Giacomantonio, Ben Bradford, Matthew Davies and Richard Martin.

This page has been archived on the Web

Information identified as archived is provided for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It is not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards and has not been altered or updated since it was archived. Please contact us to request a format other than those available.

Location

Canadian Policing Research

Resource

e-Books

Authors

Publishers

Bibliography

Includes bibliographical references.

Description

1 online resource (xv, 147 pages)

Summary

This report outlines findings from an 18-month project examining the value of mounted police in the UK. The research approach took a broad view of the concept of value in police work, including responding to and preventing crime and disorder as well as building public trust and confidence in the police, providing reassurance and visibility. The project also examines the costs associated with mounted policing, and includes an international questionnaire exercise involving senior mounted officers in other countries to place the project findings in a more global context. Chapter 2 provides an overview of mounted police work using available UK police deployment data, prior literature on mounted police and relevant theoretical literature from policing studies. Following this, Chapter 3 examines research findings from mounted police in neighbourhood patrol settings, alongside comparative data for non-mounted police in similar roles, particularly foot patrol officers. The following two chapters examine data gathered on mounted police in public order or crowd control deployments, first in the context of football policing (Chapter 4) and then in other public order settings, including research undertaken with mounted police in music festivals and political demonstrations (Chapter 5). The report then reviews focus groups discussions undertaken with football fans and non-mounted police officers (Chapter 6) to understand how mounted police are experienced by members of the public and other police. Chapter 7 examines the costs of mounted policing through two separate costing exercises, and Chapter 8 presents the findings from the international questionnaire exercise. The conclusions of the study, presented in Chapter 9, provide a synthesis of the findings. The conclusions take into account data from across the multiple and mixed-methods approaches used in the project, which provide evidence of what mounted police do, and how their value may be measured and understood. The study concludes that mounted police provide a unique policing resource that generates positive police visibility in neighbourhood contexts as well as has the capacity to offer effective response to certain public order scenarios. Based on the data, the study suggest that the highest demonstrable value of mounted police is found in neighbourhood settings, which runs contrary to the predominant opinion among police that suggests that police on horseback are primarily a public order resource. In turn, the conclusions suggest that a reorientation in this predominant opinion is warranted.

Subject

Online Access

Contents

1. Introduction. -- 1.1. Mounted policing in a context of austerity. -- 1.2. The research approach was by necessity multi-method, exploratory, flexible and iteratively defined. -- 2. An overview of mounted police work. -- 2.1. Mounted police have existed in the UK since before the modern police service. -- 2.2. Analysis conducted for this research project shows mounted police in the UK currently contribute across a wide spectrum of policing activities. -- 2.3. Understanding mounted police in the context of policing studies. -- 2.4. Summary. -- 3. Mounted police on patrol. -- 3.1. A ‘daily diary’ exercise provided an indication of the average composition of a mounted unit patrol shift. -- 3.2. The Mounted Patrol Quasi-Experiment. -- 3.3. Systematic Social Observation (SSO) of mounted police on patrol. -- 4. Mounted police in football policing. -- 4.1. Data from the UK Football Policing Unit (UKFPU) provided a starting point for understanding the effect of mounted police at football matches. -- 4.2. An analysis of a small set of matches with additional resourcing and survey data provided insight into areas not covered by UKFPU data. -- 5. Mounted police in other public order policing. -- 5.1. Systematic social observations of mounted policing at Glastonbury. -- 5.2. Mounted police in demonstration settings. -- 6. Focus groups and interviews. -- 6.1. Football fan focus groups. -- 6.2. Police focus groups. -- 6.3. Police inspector interviews. -- 7. Costs of mounted policing. -- 7.1. Police objective analysis provides a starting point for understanding the costs of mounted policing. -- 7.2. A ‘mounted premium’ developed in discussion with Directors of Finance provides an additional means to understand the costs of mounted policing. -- 7.3. While a specific cost figure remains elusive, some general conclusions can be reached regarding the costs of mounted police. -- 8. International survey of senior mounted police officers. -- 8.1. Mounted activities abroad are broadly comparable to their uses in the UK. -- 8.2. Respondents’ opinions of mounted policing emphasised the patrol and public order value of mounted units. -- 8.3. Reform of mounted sections is occurring or has recently taken place in multiple jurisdictions outside the UK. -- 9. Synthesis and conclusions. -- 9.1. Mounted police are a unique policing resource with both heightened response and public engagement value. -- 9.2. Based on the use patterns and demonstrable value of mounted police units identified by this research, consideration should be given to positioning them strategically as a resource primarily to support neighbourhood policing. -- 9.3. It is not entirely possible to separate the effects of the horses from the effects of the officers riding them. -- 9.4. The value of mounted police is not easily monetised, and estimations of their value will be related to the priorities of police in an area. -- 9.5. Suggestions for future tracking of the value of mounted police.

Date modified: